Monday, February 7, 2011

The Joshua Harris Scandal: a word to my Christian friends

When I was in early high school I read “I Kissed Dating Good-bye,” by Joshua Harris. At the time I took his word like it was scripture and decided that dating was only good for meeting Mr. Right. But I wasn’t alone! All my friends bought the theory too. Dating became scary and something that only lead to potentially deviant behaviors and temptations. Unless the Lord was in it… then of course it was going to fulfill it’s purpose.

Since I graduated from college and embarked into the cold world of singleness, I have had various dating relationships. Some were great, some were weird, some were deceptive, and some were… well just disappointing. For some reason, I’ve found that many Christians do not know how to date... including myself. There seems to be an underlying tension that we need to decide in the first two dates whether or not we are going to marry this person. I’ve thrown my heart at guys way too early and had guys throw their hearts at me before I was ready to hold it… usually with VERY LITTLE COMMUNICATION about what the other person is thinking and feeling. So like a little Red Riding Hood I ran relentlessly from the Big Bad Dating-Wolf. I know I’ve hurt a lot of wonderful people along the way… and I hate that fact. But I suppose things even themselves out as I’ve been hurt and mislead a number of times as well. At the end of it all, I don’t blame it ALL on Joshua Harris – perhaps the pressure goes deeper, to the churches seemingly unattainable standard of holiness. There are always warnings about what NOT to do when dating: don’t kiss on the first date, pre-marital sex is forbidden, make sure their “calling” aligns with yours (whatever that means), avoid the ones who drink and smoke, wait for God to bring you your “Prince” or “Princess,” opposites are good – but only in certain undefined areas, etc. But who is out there telling us HOW to date well? The only counsel I’ve received along these lines are: be yourself, wait for God’s timing, focus on what God has for you to do and it will happen someday. Not bad advice… it carries a lot of truth... but BORING!

But here’s were I divert… I find that most of my single Christian friends get really scared about dating. Freaked out to “put themselves out there,” afraid to make a mistake, and generally just wanting to find “the one.” My non-Christian friends, however, aren’t as afraid. They boldly tell people that they like them and date total strangers. If it doesn’t work out, they are a little disappointed but bounce back really fast. I think we put WAY TOO MUCH PRESSURE on the process of discovery when it could be a really fun adventure! I truly believe dating and building relationships with members of the opposite sex is extremely important in helping us realize who we are and who we aren’t! If we plan to marry, we’d better learn a thing or two about how to interact with males and females.

Dating should not be such a scary matter. Sometimes there is a “click” and it works out… and sometimes it doesn’t. We shouldn’t take these matters so personally. Christians often are afraid to hurt someone and because we’ve been conditioned to be so nice, and don’t know how to say, “Thanks, but no thanks” with tact and grace. Fearful of these confrontational realties in relationships… guys don’t ask out a girl that they think is cute until she’s hinted so overtly it’s embarrassing, and girls won’t say yes unless they know he fulfills all 24 “must-have’s” on the list she wrote in her 7th grade bible study!

This is bogus and I’m on a mission to figure out how to date well, date often, have fun, be wise, learn from lots of different guys, and believe that some day as I’m journeying forward God’s going to lead me to the one whose life is supposed to be forever intertwined with mine. Gentlemen… girls want men who are confident enough to just say what they are thinking. Ladies… quit being so controlling and picky—get to know someone for who they are not for who you hope they are. Relationships are messy… but if Jesus is in the center, it can be a beautiful mess!

So… figure out who you are, like who you are, pull up your boot-straps, and put yourself out there! What’s there to lose when there are so many new friends to be had. I’m not saying everyone should sign up for match.com… I’m just saying if you want to get married someday… you must participate in the process!

5 comments:

  1. Linds- I love this... I too took the book as "the Bible" of dating, and reality is so different for most people. I agree that we never really learned how to "date" and I laugh at the fact that I somehow stumbled through it... somehow survived :) You are great!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good thoughts.

    As with most things, I think there is a balance to be had in the whole process. I would be more inclined to blame a misunderstanding of Joshua Harris rather than the man himself.

    Things go wrong when anyone embraces something as a formula divorced from personal conviction and experience. Everyone wants a law to direct their behavior and free them from the responsibility of decision, but this is contrary to the notion of walking "in the Spirit" presented in Scripture.

    I do think his critique of many, if not most, romantic relationships was probably valid. But dating, just like drinking, is not, I don't believe, inherently wrong. Both require wisdom, responsibility, self-awareness, and a fair bit of extra cash.

    Just my two cents. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Linds,

    I love this post so much! Thanks for posting this... I think this is why we're friends. We share our opinion in so many different things - especially when it comes to guys.

    I totally agree with you. I don't have anything to say concerning the Joshua Harris book, since (when my high school friends started reading the book) I was being "nonconforming." Lol. I do have something to say about this whole dating thing.

    I think Christians get freaked out too easily. I know that in my small Christian college experience, a lot of guys get freaked out just because a girl wants to hang out. Or vice versa. They think that the girl loves him and wants to marry him. The same with the opposite. I, on the other hand, grew up having guys as my best friends. There are boundaries, but hanging out and getting to know each other isn't awkward. And getting to know each other doesn't mean we're going to get married.

    That's my thoughts on this matter.

    I'm not quite ready for an online profile on match.com, but I don't mind getting to know guys... Especially cute ones. ;P

    ReplyDelete
  4. Just to clarify... I have nothing against Joshua Harris and think he gave a lot of necessary caution about dating. I use hyperbole to make a point... so take what you think is true and ignore the rest of my ranting;0

    ReplyDelete